Hotel Reviews

Ranking the On-Site Disney World Hotels We’ve Stayed In

Deciding what Disney World hotel to stay in is one of the toughest choices when planning a vacation. There are different price points, types of rooms and locations to consider. On top of that, do you stay at the same hotel all trip or move around throughout? Unfortunately, I can’t decide all of that for you. Well, I could but it might not match what you actually want. What I can do is rank all of the Disney World resorts that I have stayed in so far.

OKW golf course

Before we get to that, a few caveats. We haven’t stayed in all of the Disney World resorts. While I’ve visited all of them, I’m going to leave the resorts I haven’t stayed in off of this list. Not surprisingly, the reason I haven’t stayed at all of them is simple – they are very expensive. The Grand Floridian remains the most expensive hotel at Disney World and the Beach Club Resort isn’t much below that. We look forward to staying there one day but for now they are left off the list.

A quick tangent – just because you’re staying at one hotel doesn’t mean you can’t walk the grounds (and eat at the restaurants) of another. In fact, I encourage people to do that. Not only will you get to see some beautiful areas Disney has created, you might come up with a better idea of where you want to stay next trip.

Polynesian sunset

Back on track, when ranking these resorts I tried to consider all factors – price, rooms, location, amenities. I was hopeful that considering all of these would even out my rankings and put some value resorts (or at least moderates) near the top of the list. Unfortunately, this wasn’t the case. While there is some parity among the values and moderates, all of the deluxe resorts or villas ended up at the top of the list. I do think there is a pretty big jump from moderate to deluxe. That doesn’t mean the other resorts are bad, on the contrary as some are quite nice, it’s just hard to ignore all the positives the deluxe resorts offer.

As the title says, this post is just sticking to all of the on-site Disney resorts. There are several Disney Springs resorts that we like, as well as the Swan & Dolphin on Disney’s Boardwalk If we were to add the Swan & Dolphin into these rankings it would likely be 5th or 6th overall, as it’s hard to beat that price and location.Check out our full review of that resort here.

With all of that out-of-the-way, it’s time to get to the rankings. If you’re interested in reading more about each resort, click on the name to see our full review.

15. All Star Music Resort

For all the flack that the All Star Resorts catch, they are starting to gain some grounds with recent room remodels. Most of that comes down to value. All Star Music Resort does have the worst rooms on this list (although they’re getting an update and the amenities aren’t as enjoyable as others. Having said that, I don’t think they are so bad that it makes up for the difference in cost. If you can find a standard room right around $100 or a family suite for $200 then All Star Music Resort holds some value. I also think this resort has a more prevalent and well executed theme than Pop Century and Art of Animation, if that’s important to you. I’m in the minority when it comes to thinking that All Star Music is not far below the next few on the list but if you find the right price and time then staying here is not a bad option.

All Star Music Resort pool

14. Art of Animation Resort

Art of Animation and Pop Century will always be linked. Unfortunately, Art of Animation falls behind Pop Century due to the higher price tag. The hotel does have better amenities than the one directly across the lake. The pool is similar but with a few more interesting quirks. The food court has a similar layout but slightly better food. Unfortunately, the rooms aren’t as nice as Pop Century’s updated rooms and they come at a higher cost. All things being even, I’d probably pick Art of Animation over Pop Century but the resort is almost always more expensive than Pop Century, hence the lower ranking. The Disney Skyliner is a huge bonus to both of these resorts though.

AoA outside

13. Pop Century Resort

Pop Century certainly has its place among the Disney World Resorts. But when compared to the other resorts on this list, Pop Century doesn’t excel in many categories. The rooms are slightly nicer than the All Star Resorts, the pools and food court are decent but nothing spectacular. The proximity to Epcot and Art of Animation is nice but no better than anywhere else on the list. Theming is somewhat lacking throughout the resort or is so broad that anything can fit. Cost is far less, and that’s great, as is the addition of the Disney Skyliner which moves the hotel up a few spots.

Pop Century sign

12. Coronado Springs Resort

Coronado Springs is another resort that has been plussed with new restaurants and rooms, including a giant new tower. We’re lukewarm on the renovation and the hotel largely stays in the same place in our rankings as before. I think this hotel is fairly interesting with distinct southwest architecture and a beautiful lake to walk around. Coronado Springs also offers one of the best pools in all of Walt Disney World. The counter-service dining is the best of any moderate resort. I find the rooms here to be bland and the theming lacking continuity. Still, I could understand those that move Coronado up on the list and finding the hotel under $180/night is a steal.

Coronado Springs fountain

11. Saratoga Springs Resort

The lowest ranked deluxe resort is still a solid option if you can find the right deal. Saratoga Springs caters to those who want more of a laid back vacation with lots of time at Disney Springs. Themed to upstate New York, we don’t find the resort to be enveloping in terms of theme but it is beautiful. Saratoga’s other detraction is how spread out the resort is, making the bus times a bit frustrating. There is a chance to find Saratoga Springs Resort under $250/night and then we’d recommend it (or if you’re looking for a room to accommodate a big group), otherwise there are moderate resorts we like more.

Saratoga Springs fountain

10. Port Orleans – Riverside

Port Orleans – Riverside ranks above Coronado because of two factors. One, the grounds are absolutely stunning with beautiful buildings, paths and architecture all around. Two, the theme is wonderful and executed to perfection. Acting as a town outside of New Orleans, I find Riverside a quiet escape to the chaos of the parks. The pool isn’t great but being near French Quarter is a plus, as is the boat ride transportation to Disney Springs.

Port Orleans greenery

9. Old Key West Resort 

Old Key West’s pros and cons are more extreme than most other on the list. We’ll start with the pros. Old Key West’s location and transportation are strong, offering easy (boat) access to Disney Springs. The room size is also advantageous, with a bigger footprint than any other Disney resort. I also find the pool area to be quite nice and the walking to be beautiful. Unfortunately, the resort looks a little older (and it is). The theme is executed but might not have been the best idea as I find it boring. There are times when you can find Old Key West at a significant discount and booking then is a solid choice. Also, if you want a larger room then I’d absolutely recommend Old Key West.

Old Key West pool

8. Caribbean Beach Resort

Caribbean Beach has gained the most ground in these rankings thanks to the resort’s massive renovation and the Disney Skyliner opening, both of which have helped the resort tremendously. The grounds are very pretty and the proximity to Epcot is a definite plus. On top of that, the main pool is very fun. Caribbean Beach has a large footprint and takes a while to walk around, which can be a negative after a long day in the parks. That can be negated thanks to the options on the Skyliner stations and multiple bus stops.

7. Bay Lake Tower at Contemporary Resort

Maybe my most controversial pick on this list as I imagine it would be very high on some lists. If this was actually the Contemporary Resort and staying inside the A-frame then I’d have a hard time not putting it at number one I’m guessing. But Bay Lake Tower isn’t much of a consideration for the number one spot as the resort has no theme and the rooms were nice but not exciting. The location can’t be beat, steps away from Magic Kingdom and a monorail ride away from Epcot. Still, Bay Lake Tower can’t overcome being one of the dullest resorts at Disney – especially compared to what the top 3 offer.

Contemporary from boat

6. Boardwalk Inn

This resort was the hardest to rank, mainly because there’s a big jump from 7 to 6. All of the top 6 have a stake at being number 1 for me. For now, Boardwalk Inn falls in this slot mainly because I think the rooms lack character. That said, the resort has our favorite location of any at Disney World. The pool is fun and the surrounding Boardwalk area is really enjoyable to walk around. While a deluxe resort, there are times when you can find a decent rate (under $300/night). It’s also a good value for DVC owners or those renting points.

Boardwalk sunset across water

5. Port Orleans French Quarter

While French Quarter can’t boast the incredible location that the Contemporary offers, it does have a distinct theme at much lower prices. The resort is nestled right up against the river and offers an idealized New Orleans for guests to enjoy. There is boat transportation offered to Disney Springs and the resort is close to Epcot. While French Quarter doesn’t offer everything that a deluxe resort does, being able to walk to Port Orleans Riverside makes for a quasi-deluxe with a laid back atmosphere and beautiful theme.

Cool guy POFQ

4. Wilderness Lodge

Wilderness Lodge is a resort with incredible character, Wilderness Lodge’s beauty is jaw-dropping. The lobby, pool, room, restaurants, and location are all top-notch. Every aspect is as solid as it gets and the price point is on the lower end of the deluxe resorts. That Wilderness Lodge isn’t in the top 3 is no fault of its own. The top 3 just provide a little extra something to put them over the top that Wilderness Lodge doesn’t quite have.

Wilderness Lodge inside

3. Polynesian Village Resort

If you take away the extremely high price point then the Polynesian probably takes over the first spot on this list. The resort has some of our favorite rooms in Walt Disney World. On top of that, the Polynesian has a well executed theme, incredible location, an amazing pool and one of the best dining scenes of any resort at Walt Disney World. The downside is that guests will definitely be paying for all of that. If we’re picking nits, the Poly might not have the same type of charm that Wilderness Lodge or French Quarter has but it makes up for it in plenty of other ways. If you have the means then stay here, even though it isn’t a good value.

Poly volcano pool day

2. Animal Kingdom Lodge

While Wilderness Lodge beats Animal Kingdom Lodge in location, AKL wins out in every other aspect. There are beautiful, original rooms that fit the theme perfectly. The pools are very nice, if not spectacular. Food is a spot where this resort excels with three of the best table-service restaurants in Walt Disney World. Oh, and there are animals right outside of the room. This distinction alone would make Animal Kingdom Lodge incredible, thankfully they didn’t stop there. The resort offers more extras than others as well, with free tours of their dining locations, open fire-pits and much more. Melissa and I both agreed that if just looking at the resort alone, Animal Kingdom Lodge would be number one. Factoring in location changed the top spot though. Fortunately, you can find pretty decent values at Animal Kingdom Lodge with rooms sometimes around $250/night. If you can’t stay there though then go visit the hotel, it’s worth your time.

AKL deck view

1. Yacht Club Resort

Frankly, if just considering the room, lobby and them the Yacht Club would probably be in the 3-5 range on this list. Where the resort excels is the outstanding pool (Stormalong Bay) and location. Walking to and from Epcot and Hollywood Studios is my favorite location of any resort, even more than the Magic Kingdom resorts. And that pool is like a miniature water park, except more relaxing. If you can swing it even for a night or two, Yacht (and Beach) Club is an incredible place to stay.

That does it for my resort rankings so far.  I’ll update the list as we stay at other resorts over the years.  Let me know any questions or thoughts down below in the comments!

If you enjoy what you’re reading on Wandering in Disney please subscribe to the blog and like our Facebook page. You can find both of those on the right side of this page. Thank you for reading, we really appreciate it!

3 replies »

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s