Columbia Harbor House is a counter-service restaurant in Walt Disney World’s Magic Kingdom. Residing in Liberty Square, Columbia Harbor House serves American fare and specializes in seafood. The restaurant does take part in the Disney Dining Plan as a counter-service credit but doesn’t accept any other discounts. In this post, we’ll review Columbia Harbor House’s atmosphere, cuisine and value.

Magic Kingdom’s dining options have historically been a sore spot for an otherwise strong park. Counter-service dining is especially poor with very few interesting options and a lack of quality. This was especially true when Columbia Harbor House was closed for the better part of the year after Magic Kingdom opened its gates back up post pandemic. Thankfully, the restaurant has regained its ‘mainstay’ status at the park.

Due to its spot in Liberty Square, the restaurant feels like a little, cozy hole in the wall you might wander into in a seaside town. I find the restaurant to be very welcoming with its maritime décor. The restaurant also flows well from the European-inspired Fantasyland to the colonized Liberty Square. The architecture and story fit the thought of traveling from Europe to the American colonies. Once reaching the colonies, Columbia Harbor House is the type of warm restaurant that you’d want to find. Of course, if you lived long enough to see the colonies then this whole idea of a theme park might be pretty confusing.

There are plenty of seats on both floors. The top floor used to be one of the hidden gems in Magic Kingdom, a quiet respite with some fun views out the window. Now, both floors are usually typically pretty busy but I still recommend sitting upstairs. At times that area can still be fairly empty. Along with that, there’s some windows to look out and enjoy people passing by.

As for the food, the menu mostly consists of seafood. Columbia Harbor House has a nice mix of fried and grilled food, along with a salad mixed in. Everything we’ve ever tried at the restaurant has come out fresh. Although the menu has changed slightly over the years, the quality has always been solid and a tick above most other counter-service spots in Magic Kingdom.

One of the best entrees is the Lobster Roll served with fries. When it comes to the sandwich, I was pleasantly surprised. There was not very much filling in the sandwich and a ton of lobster. The flavor wasn’t as rich as some lobster rolls I’ve had but this was still delicious, mostly thanks to the richness of the seafood in the sandwich. The fries were the same as all other Walt Disney World counter-service fries, meaning they weren’t very good. At $16.99, the Lobster Roll is a decent value especially considering the amount of lobster in the sandwich. I would happily recommend the dish.

We’ve also tried the Grilled Salmon which is served with Rice and Green Beans. The salmon was cooked well and had a somewhat sweet glaze to it. The portion size was, as you can see, fairly large and filling. This isn’t your typical counter-service entrée, it was fresh and delicious. Outside of a few salads, this is the most well rounded counter-service option at Magic Kingdom currently. The green beans were fine and somewhat fresh but a little mushy. The rice is nothing to write home about. There wasn’t much flavor in it but I thought it was a nice starch to finish off the dish. All in all, this was a great option and a steal at only $14.79.

Another favorite is the recent addition of the Shrimp Boil! This consists of Shrimp, Potatoes, Corn, and Andouille Sausage cooked in a Spiced Broth served with warm Parker House Rolls. Another hearty and filling dish, there’s plenty to eat here. Generally, I find Walt Disney World’s shrimp to be surprisingly good and these are no exception. They soak up the broth and are plump, juicy shrimp. I also liked the sausage, adding a little spice to the dish. If I had one bone to pick, it’s that I wish there was more broth to it. Otherwise, this is the most inventive counter-service option at the park and worth the $16.29

On other trips, I’ve tried the Trio Platter. This consists of Fried Shrimp, Chicken Strips, and Battered Fish served with Hushpuppies and choice of side. Trio Platter is one name for it. Tray Full of Fried Food is probably more accurate but might not be as good of a seller. Both the fish and shrimp were pretty good, with good flavor and a batter that wasn’t overly greasy. There’s nothing that sets it apart from standard fried fish or shrimp but it’s also not worse than that. As far as the Chicken Strips go, they were okay.

The whole dish was decent and definitely the most filling thing on the menu. I also liked the Hush Puppies pretty well but, as is the theme with this option, it wasn’t anything outstanding. The best part of the Trio Platter is the value. This is a lot of food for $14.29 and one of the best choices in the park for value.

We went with the seasonal cobbler for dessert and thought it was pretty average. The addition of the cream that you can see on top was nice. Otherwise there was nothing that stood out about the cobbler. I regret not getting the Boston Cream Pie as I think that’s a slightly more original counter-service dessert. Maybe next time! For now, desserts aren’t listed on the menu but they seem to come and go at the restaurant.

Columbia Harbor House offers some surprisingly fresh and delicious entrees at decent prices. The salmon is likely the healthiest non-salad counter-service option in Magic Kingdom. The Lobster Roll, Shrimp Boil and Trio Platter both offer some of the best value around. I do think that the restaurant could benefit from having nicer plates and cutlery instead of paper and plastic but that’s a minor gripe.

If you enjoy seafood then Columbia Harbor House is one of the better counter-service options in Disney World. While the menu isn’t extremely diverse in its offerings there are different selections that could fit the whole family. All in all, Columbia Harbor House is easily Magic Kingdom’s best counter-service restaurant right now.

Overall Rating – 8.5/10

Have you tried Columbia Harbor House? Let us know your thoughts on the restaurant in the comments! Planning a trip to Walt Disney World? Check out our planning guide to help you along the way! Looking for discount tickets to Disney World? Check out this site! If you enjoy what you’re reading here at Wandering in Disney please subscribe to our blog and like our social media pages. You can accomplish both of those things on the right side of this page. If you have any Disney Parks questions please send us an email at wanderingindisney@gmail.com or leave a comment. We’d be happy to help and thank you for reading!